Browse Source

Improved analyze_paper.

pull/288/head
Daniel Miessler 8 months ago
parent
commit
0188c915a7
  1. 7
      patterns/analyze_paper/system.md

7
patterns/analyze_paper/system.md

@ -60,15 +60,18 @@ Take a deep breath and think step by step about how to best accomplish this goal
- Theoretical to Empirical is how much the paper is based on purely speculative or theoretical ideas or actual data on a scale of 1 - 10. Note: Theoretical papers can still be rigorous and novel and should not be penalized overall for being Theoretical alone. - Theoretical to Empirical is how much the paper is based on purely speculative or theoretical ideas or actual data on a scale of 1 - 10. Note: Theoretical papers can still be rigorous and novel and should not be penalized overall for being Theoretical alone.
EXAMPLE CHART for 7, 5, 9 SCORES (fill in the actual scores):
Known [------7---] Novel Known [------7---] Novel
Weak: [----5-----] Rigorous Weak: [----5-----] Rigorous
Theoretical [--------9-] Empirical Theoretical [--------9-] Empirical
END EXAMPLE CHART
- Final Score: - Final Score:
- A - F based on the scores above, conflicts of interest, and the overall quality of the paper. Give a 15-word explanation for the grade. - A - F based on the scores above, conflicts of interest, and the overall quality of the paper. Give a 15-word explanation for the grade.
# RATING NOTES # RATING NOTES
- If the paper makes claims and presents stats but doesn't show how it arrived at these stats, then the Methodology Transparency would be low, and the RIGOR score should be lowered as well. - If the paper makes claims and presents stats but doesn't show how it arrived at these stats, then the Methodology Transparency would be low, and the RIGOR score should be lowered as well.
@ -85,6 +88,8 @@ Theoretical [--------9-] Empirical
- Output all sections above. - Output all sections above.
- For the chart, use the actual scores to fill in the chart.
- For the findings and other analysis sections, write at the 9th-grade reading level. This means using short sentences and simple words/concepts to explain everything. - For the findings and other analysis sections, write at the 9th-grade reading level. This means using short sentences and simple words/concepts to explain everything.
- Ensure there's a blank line between each bullet of output. - Ensure there's a blank line between each bullet of output.

Loading…
Cancel
Save